SUBTEXTS

Face it.  Most of us like to think of ourselves as honest, even when we’re not.  The idea of being a “straight-shooter” and “straight talker” is what upstanding citizens and human beings do.  But the truth is, we all lie sometimes.  Or, to put it more equivocally, we equivocate.  Or obfuscate. Maybe to stay out of trouble, or to avoid an argument which might harm a relationship,  or we aren’t sure what the right thing to say is, or we don’t want to hurt someone’s feelings. Whatever the reason, we straddle the fence by saying one thing while meaning (and conveying) another.

Those of us who have lived long enough have probably been on both sides of the fence.  We have used these subterfuges, so of course we recognize them when other people use them on us.

For example, when M would rather not do something, he usually says, “I’ll do it tomorrow,” or “When I get to it.” If he says, “In a minute,” it means tomorrow.  “Later,” means I have a fighting chance.  And “When I get to it,” means “never gonna happen.”

One of my favorites: I had a very opinionated neighbor who thought she had better taste than everyone else’s on our street.  She would give your new sofa, or dress for an upcoming wedding, or the cookies you just baked the once-over, then put her hand on her chin and tap it a few times like she was thinking hard, and say, on a big exhaled breath, “You like it?????” It was crystal clear to anyone who faced that carefully placed hand-on-chin, and those disapproving eyes that what she was really saying was: much as you might like the sofa (dress, cookies) she didn’t no, not one bit, in fact they were revolting and you might actually be an idiot for buying/baking them.

Have you ever run into someone you haven’t seen in a while who says, with kindly concern, “Are you okay?”  I thought about this the other day, when a friend greeted me with, “Are you tired?” The words may be all about concern for your wellbeing, but can there be any doubt that you look like holy hell at that moment? My favorite in this category was the delicious/malicious  putdown when an acquaintance asked me if I were okay because she thought I might be cyanotic. Turned out she didn’t care for my bluish-purple lipstick.

It works the other way too: someone who acts overly surprised at how grrrrreat you look when you are just your ordinary self which makes you wonder how bad you looked the last time you met.  “You look fabulous!” makes me want to argue the person out of thinking I look any different from the way I usually look.  (Or else I drive myself crazy thinking how I can live up to this fabulousness the next time we meet.)

Lots of times we obfuscate to save someone’s feelings.  Like, have you ever sat in the audience of a performance by someone you know, wondering what you are going to say when you go backstage?  I’ve perfected the one word that can stand in for anything from “That was awful, I’m so sorry,” to “That was marvelous.”  Just say, “Oh, wow.  Wow, darling, wow.”  And smile. Or, when someone you love comes home with a terrible haircut, the only thing to say is, “I love it!”  And smile.

Here are some common things people say when they really mean other things:

Simple, good for any occasion: “Okay” which, with a rhythmic or tonal adjustment means “not okay.”  (Or, if you are a minimalist, “Mmmhmm,” which stands for “That’s what you  say.”)

When making plans: “Do you really want to go?”  means “Let’s stay home.”

A discussion closer: “If you say so,” means “Not true, but I’m not about to argue.”

“What do you think of so and so?” means “I didn’t like him and I’m looking for company.”

“Let me sleep on it, ” in the workplace means “no.”

At home: “Let’s sleep on it” means “give me enough time to figure out a good reason to say no.”

During a long phone call: “Let me let you go,” means “I’m done. I have to end this NOW.”

Let me let you go.

 

 

Advertisements

About betteann

Writer, teacher, cook
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to SUBTEXTS

  1. genkazdin says:

    Oh dear, oh dear. For the last little while I have had this problem. I do not like euphemisms for straightforward words. Pat has not transitioned, nor gained wings. He died. I understand and accept that many do not like actually saying that. Right now, it is better for me to let those words pass rather than be bitchy to someone trying to ease my sorrows. But I like ‘Let’s sleep on it’. Sometimes a quiet mull can show a compromise or a confirmation of an initial reaction. Gut reactions can be accurate and important. They also can be deceptive, hiding a fear of something new, change, or risky. A time for thought can reveal something we are ignoring that needs to be dealt with before moving forward. Taking that time when a decision must be made is not a rejection, it is a re-evaluation. A closer look at someone else’s point of view. A good thing.

    • betteann says:

      Oh, you and I agree on “passed.” ( All though “transitioned” makes me giggle and “gained wings” is a hoot. ) Died it is. And “sleeping on it” is benign if it’s authentic, but often it is a euphemism for closing the subject. Love that you weigh in.

  2. philip schaenman says:

    I love the new TV show, the Good Doctor, about a surgeon who is autistic, and often blurts out things bluntly, without euphemisms or subtexts. The show has explored how his peers and bosses try to explain when you have to use euphemisms. or speak around a subject, or at least have a more gentle way of putting things. Like when he charges into a patient’s room after having tests ordered, and just says “You’re going to die.” .

    it is especially difficult for men to respond to a woman wearing a new garment, or new makeup, when she asks “how do I look?” , and you are thinking “like hell.” I used to tend toward telling the truth, but no more, except to my wife, who is the only woman i know who can take an honest opinion because she has enough self-confidence not to care what others say, and likes an honest opinion which she may or may not agree with.

    Also a point of computer grammar. “A tart take on the world” would be translated by some computerized translation programs into “a tart’s take on the world.” That version might increase readership.

    • betteann says:

      Thanks for weighing in, Phil. Re: the name: That’s why I hate computer auto-correct. It doesn’t get it right. “Tart” means tangy, as you know, and it is an adjective, not a noun.

  3. Claire O’Brien says:

    Another winner!!! It’s so interesting to “read” yourself and realize you are not so unique in your understanding and response as a human being. Affirming and at the same time humbling🤗🤗

  4. Michael Schwartz says:

    I find the “passed on” wording, a bit strange. Passed on to what? Some use “making the transition”, in the same way. The reality is that no one knows what comes next, after you die. Not to belittle those who have their personal religious beliefs, but they are faith based, and not knowledge based.I think that I do the same as M with chores I really don’t want to do. It is a way out, although, not an honest one. Does one win more points just saying “I do not want to do this, and no one is going to make me”? The dilemma is seeing someone looking gaunt, or tired, or ill, unless you are autistic, you look for something positive to say, Love your blogging, Bette Ann.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s